Loading today's hours...
Spend $55 or More and Get FREE Wings!
FREE FIRED WOOD WINGS
Catania’s Pizzeria
Order online and get our Fired Wood Wings at no cost. Slow-cooked over real wood fire for an authentic smoky flavor—crispy outside, tender inside, and finished with our signature sauces.
This offer is available only for online orders. Enjoy real fire, real flavor… and yes, they’re free.
FREE FIRED WOOD WINGS
Welcome to Catania"s
At Catania’s Pizza, we believe great food brings people together. Located at 1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, our restaurant has become a favorite spot for anyone who loves classic pizza and Italian dishes made with care. We’re proud to be part of this community, serving fresh, flavorful food every day in a space where everyone feels at home. From a quick lunch to a family dinner, you’ll always find something to enjoy here.
Freshly baked in our wood-fired oven
Our menu is simple, but every bite counts. We make each dish with fresh ingredients, rich flavors, and quality you can count on. Alongside our classics, we serve crispy empanadas that are perfect for sharing and fresh salads for those who want something light and flavorful. Everything we prepare comes from our passion for good food and our commitment to doing it right. When you dine with us, you’re getting more than just a meal—you’re getting something made with pride and consistency.
Pizza Made with Pride, Served with Care
At Catania’s Pizza, we keep things simple—fresh dough, rich sauce, and the right balance of toppings. Every pizza we make starts with quality ingredients and ends with that perfect, satisfying slice. From classic favorites to specialty creations, each one is crafted with consistency and care. Dine in, order out, or share with family—our pizza delivers comfort, flavor, and a touch of tradition in every bite.
Order from Our Website
Enjoy your favorites from Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake without the wait. Ordering online is quick, simple, and convenient. Choose what you love, place your order, and we’ll have it ready for pickup or delivered right to your door. At home, at work, or planning a family meal, we make it easy to get great food fast. Skip the lines and order directly from our website today for the best experience and fresh, made-to-order meals every time.
Fresh from Our Kitchen
Get a glimpse of the food we proudly serve every day at Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake. Each dish is made with care, using fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes that bring people together. Browse our gallery and see why our guests keep coming back for the quality, flavor, and comfort found in every meal.
Catering Made Easy
Bring the flavors of Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake to your next event. Our catering service makes it simple to serve fresh, crowd-pleasing food that everyone will enjoy. From small gatherings to large celebrations, we prepare everything with the same care and quality you’d expect from our kitchen. Let us handle the food so you can focus on enjoying the moment.
Relax and Dine In Comfort
Step inside Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake and feel right at home. Enjoy your meal in our cozy indoor dining area or take in the fresh air on our outdoor patio, where dogs are welcome. Our casual, friendly space is perfect for family meals, quick lunches, or laid-back dinners. Take a seat, unwind, and enjoy the simple comfort of good pizza, good company, and a welcoming place to relax.
Visit Us Today📍
Stop by Catania’s Pizza – Mohegan Lake and enjoy great food served with care. We’re located at 1821 E Main St, Mohegan Lake, NY 10547, right in the heart of the community. Join us for a casual meal indoors or relax outside with your dog on our patio. We’re open Sunday through Saturday, 11 AM–9 PM, so there’s always time to drop in for your favorites.
Come by, grab a seat, or place your order to go — we’re always ready to serve you with a smile.
What our guests are saying
First time here and would highly recommend. The service and food were great. Perfectly cooked pizza and the gentleman making the pizza was super nice and welcoming.
Mike G.
10/10 Food is amazing, especially margherita pizza and wings. Highly recommend. Super fresh, consistent, best in the area. Everyone is super nice.
Kristella P.
Love the pizza from this place and i’m so happy they’re now open on sundays! The google page hasn’t updated it yet but i came in sunday and they were open.
Anthony P.
Featuring
Catering
Delivery
Takeout
Dine In
Outdoor Seating
Dogs Allowed Outside
Catania's Pizza - Mohegan Lake Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Supreme Pizza, Minestrone Soup, Fried Calamari, Garlic Knots, Salads, Burgers, French Fries, Antipasto Salad, Shrimp Scampi, Pasta, Cheesecake, Tiramisu, Bolognese, Cheese Steak, Mozzarella Sticks, Stromboli, Soup, Hawaiian Pizza, Carbonara, Meatballs, Onion Rings, Tuna, Lasagna, Grilled Chicken, Ranch Burger, Calzone, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Zuppa Di Pesce, Philly Cheese Steak, Garlic Bread, BBQ, Caesar Salad, House Burger, Chicken Parmesan, Blt, Dessert, Wings, Margherita Pizza, White Pizza, Meat Lovers Pizza, Cowboy Burger, Cobb Salad, Calamari, Chicken Tenders, Fries, Greek Salad, Seafood, Tortellini In Brodo, Catering, Arugula Salad, Grilled Salmon, Vegetarian Food, Minestrone, Shrimp, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Salmon, New York Italian Restaurant, Ravioli, and Tortellini
Where are you located?
We are located in Mohegan Lake, NY at 1821 E Main St
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Mohegan Lake, Lake Mohegan, Shrub Oak, Lake Peekskill, Roe Park, Crompond, Jefferson Valley-Yorktown, Van Cortlandtville, Toddville, Gallows Hill, Continental Village, Oceola Lake, Yorktown, Jefferson Valley, Peekskill, Pleasantside, Graymoor, Furnace Woods, Cortlandt, and Sunnybrook.
Our location
